The case for christ records lee strobels attempt to determine if theres credible evidence that jesus of nazareth really is the son of god. The case for islamochristian civilization is a necessary read for every student and scholar of the middle east, as well as anyone seeking arguments for an. Islam is the natural culmination of both judaism and christiantiy, and never persecuted jews as did christianity. Export a ris file for endnote, procite, reference manager, zotero, mendeley export a text file for bibtex note. The case for islamochristian civilization in searchworks. Until recently 90% of jews lived comfortably not with christians in medieval europe, but in northwest africa and the levant under muslim rule. Oct 06, 2004 conventional wisdom maintains that the differences between islam and christianity are irreconcilable. The case for islamochristian civilization shifted paradigmatic understandings of islamic and latin christian civilizational histories by proposing that they be viewed as sibling, rather than opposed or discrete, civilizations through the early modern period. Of or pertaining to judaism, islam, and christianity. Conventional wisdom maintains that the differences between islam and christianity are irreconcilable. Project muse the case for islamochristian civilization. The case for islamochristian civilization edition 1 by. The case for islamochristian civilization internet archive.
Bulliett, professor of history at columbia university and former director of its middle east institute. The case for islamochristian civilization shifted paradigmatic understandings of islamic and latin. Presenting comparatively major themes of historical development in the middle east and the west, bulliet argues that the two are best understood not in terms of. Though islamochristian civilization may be a neologism, it is a creative key term that this book will make into a household word. What if, instead of asking what went wrong in the muslim world, we sought to find out what went on. While the war on terrorism tempts americans to perceive the relations between the west and the islamic world as a clash of us against them, such a perspective is both inaccurate and dangerous, argues. Richard bulliet argues this in the case for islamo christian civilization 2006. World historians will enjoy and profit from this wise and wonderful book with an eyeopening approach succinctly captured in its title. It is an updating of essays and reflections that he has. The view from the edge 1994, conversion to islam in the medieval period 1979, the camel and the wheel 1975, and the patricians of nishapur 1972. Since 911 americans have been subjected to a relentless parade of experts, from missionaries to historians to special interest advocates, all of whom warn about the difference and danger of islam. Bulliet disagrees, and in this fresh, provocative book he looks beneath the rhetoric of hatred and misunderstanding to challenge prevailing and misleading views of islamic history and a clash of civilizations. The first of four chapters fits the title of the book as bulliet.
Hardcover w dust jacket description from the publisher. Carl brown, foreign affairs a positive and challenging proposal, underscoring the importance of the phases we use in defining our world. The case for islamochristian civilization richard w. Christian civilizational histories by proposing that they be. Because the middle east is the cradle of the judeo islamo christian paradigm, the sectarian milieu, as john wansbrough put it in a fundamental book on the semantic structure of religions,24 has remained relevant worldwide. Bulliet disagrees, and in this fresh, provocative book he looks beneath the rhetoric of hatred and misunderstanding to challenge prevailingand misleadingviews of islamic history and a clash of civilizations. What if, instead of viewing the muslim world as a fundamentally different other, we saw it as sharing a common cultural tradition. National security archive guatemalan documentation. I can see why bulliet didnt choose to title his book the case for seeing our civilization as islamo christian, but that is the book he wrote. The case for islamochristian civilization by richard w.
The correct terminology would be islamochristian vs judaic civilizations, as there is a direct continuity between christianity and islam, which have more in common with each other than either has with judaism. Mar 01, 2007 recalling that judeo christian civilization is a term originally coined by nietzsche to deride both and was adopted only after world war ii, when its acceptance changed the master narrative, he hopes to do the same by proposing an islamo christian kinship that will help americans find a common ground with the muslims in their midst. The case for islamochristian civilization by richard bulliet pdf. Bulliet born 1940 is a professor of history at columbia university who specializes in the history of islamic society and institutions, the. Bulliett, professor of history at columbia university and former director of its middle east institute, offers a startlingly original interpretation that challenges not only conventional. Though islamo christian civilization may be a neologism, it is a creative key term that this book will make into a household word. The case for islamochristian civilization in searchworks catalog. While the war on terrorism tempts americans to perceive the relations between the west and the islamic world as a clash of us against them, such a perspective is both inaccurate and. Conventional wisdom maintains that the differences between islam and christianity are. Noted middle easternislamist scholar and historian richard w. While he probably wouldnt oppose such a project, bulliets project is something else. While on one hand extremely sympathetic to the goals richard bulliet aspires to in the case for islamo christian civilization, i can nonetheless find a significant number of problems with the book on the other.
The book consists primarily of interviews between strobel a former legal editor at the chicago tribune and biblical scholars such. The case for islamochristian civilization columbia university press. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link. The notion that something went wrong presumes a comparative perspective in.
To begin with, this is not a cohesive or wellorganized argument. The case for islamo christian civilization is a necessary read for every student and scholar of the middle east, as well as anyone seeking arguments for an alliance of civilizations in todays world, not a clash. A preeminent middle east scholar argues that beginning in the 1950s american policymakers misread the muslim world. Receiving a merina blessing is not just the receipt of supernatural benediction, as it is in the judeoislamochristian tradition, it is something which. The case for islamochristian civilization by rothman. Nielsen book data summary conventional wisdom maintains that the differences between islam and christianity are irreconcilable. The case for islamochristian civilization foreign affairs. The case for islamo christian civilization shifted paradigmatic understandings of islamic and latin christian civilizational histories by proposing that they be viewed as sibling, rather than opposed or discrete, civilizations through the early modern period. The case for islamochristian civilization 2004, in press, the columbia history of the twentieth century ed.
790 440 580 515 1499 1648 279 1255 1440 294 838 938 825 899 1426 778 254 1346 147 181 983 143 687 1264 29 678 1610 1167 882 1361 25 1205 920 165 22 1043 1382 749 577 124